RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/wintercycling • … • u/DrDerpberg

Are disc brakes and front suspension recommended for winter commuting?

Hi everyone, about to pull the trigger on a dedicated winter bike. I've narrowed it down to 2, essentially the same bike except for $110CAD more I can get disc brakes + front suspension. I'm curious to hear people's thoughts on brake type and if suspension is worth it.

Rim brakes/stiff fork version:

https://www.decathlon.ca/en/p/8771010/hybrid-bike-riverside-120#/?queryID=828dd68b1890269486339e72378629a7

Disc brakes + front suspension version:

https://www.decathlon.ca/en/p/8941685/hybrid-bike-disc-brake-riverside-500#/?queryID=a18471b3099a38cd017b456414011679

I'm kind of torn, in that for a "summer" bike the discs alone would be worth the upgrade. I'm less sure about winter specifically - do disc brakes perform better because they don't get wet and grimy like rims, or are they worse because they're trickier to clean and maintain? Does front suspension just create an additional spot salty water can get in and wreck stuff, and kind of give way instead of smashing through snow and hurt traction? Or do they help stay on track by reducing how much you get knocked off track?

My commute is mostly bike path, with some taking the lane/riding in the plowed slushy crap at the side of the road. I'm looking for reliability and ease of repair, knowing that I can only hose the bike off at one end of my commute I fully expect to be replacing chains, cables, derailleurs etc. every other year at best (hence why I'm going for a fairly inexpensive bike with easy-to find, cheap parts).

Thanks!

— 0