Withings+ off the rails
Got a congratulatory message from Withings+ today on losing 35+ lbs of body fat in a mere week of half-hour walks and working at a desk all day.
Sometimes the jokes just write themselves....
The big surprise was it brought up my DEXA scores. I've been trying to manipulate the summary messages to give me better results, but it won't let me aside from the summary on the Readiness tab.
The AI Agent has actually been pretty useful - I've been prodding it to see how some of the metrics are calculated. It doesn't divulge proprietary information, but it does give enough info to see where the numbers come from.
None of that is an issue, it's the calculation of the split between body fat % and muscle mass % that's the error throwing off my results, and I assume everyone else's too (who are reading low body fat %).
One other odd observation is the AI agent cannot see hydration levels. So that weight gain shown above is actually 5-8 lb of water weight gain (plainly seen in the app). Because it cannot see this, it just assumes changes in fat and muscle mass instead of giving a more enlightened answer (muscle repair and glycogen stores).