One year with my ATC
I finished tool chest about one year ago and put my hand tools in it.
About two years ago I decided to start focusing on handwork. I have a good machine setup but I found myself gravitating toward a handtool/machine combination setup. At first, I kept the tools in a old file cabinet, but it sucked. I couldn't find anything.
After seeing some folks post pictures of their completed chests I bought the book and decided to give it a try. I picked up a marking gage, dovetail saw, and some poplar and got to work. After about four months (life got in the way....) I finished it. After a year I have to say I really like it. I'm not a real super organized guy, so I really like the free form trays and bottom. I did add a tool rack on the front so I can get to my dovetail saw and other stuff easily. I also have my chisels hung off the middle diver so I can easily get the one I need. The other things I use frequently (like the block plane) move to the top and are just one grab away. The middle seems to be odds and ends and the bottom has the large things like brace,
http://imgur.com/wZw1Flt
I heard a lot of people complain that their backs would hurt from bending over, I haven't experienced it. What I'll usually do is open up the lid and just walk back and forth to get what I need out of it (my shop is a 1.5 car garage). As I finish with a tool, I clean it, put tallow on it, and put it back. This arrangement so far has worked pretty well. I also haven't had any problems with rust, the chest keeps things nice and clean.
If you are curious about it, I'd encourage to give the chest a try. I suck at dovetails, but by the end, they looked 85% less crappy then when I started. If you end up not liking it, you can re-purpose it or sell it at a flea market and tell them it's your long lost brother's friend's great grandfather's uncle's chest from England.