If ‘elves’ in a world requires the extraction of wombs from ‘orcs’ just to reproduce, does that justify the genocide of the ‘elves’?
This is a broader question for general worldbuilding, but I’m using ‘elves’ and ‘orcs’ as placeholder names instead of typing out “intelligent species” for the sake of brevity (although the usage of these labels maps to my own work, but I’m going to leave that in the context comment because I understand the rules against self-promotion.)
As for the “womb-stealing” thing, yes, that’s what I’m using in my own work, and I am using that as an example for shock value to encourage discussion, but for the sake of this argument *we could probably say that any sort of predatory relationship between one intelligent species and the other would count*. So, you could replace it with “elves require the consumption of orc flesh just to survive”, etc.
First, here’s my take (but I’d love to know yours, and how you wrestle with similar moral/philosophical problems stemming from predatory relationships of the denizens of your own worldbuilding)-
**The case for genocide:**
Let’s take mosquitos for example. Yes, it’s a relatively harmless example, but we understand that mosquitos do not fit any highly necessary ecological niche that justifies their survival. Meanwhile, they spread malaria. For that reason, human beings have decided that it is in the *net moral good* for us to eradicate mosquitos entirely.
For these ‘elves’ in question, I’ll take a *deontological view* for the case for genocide, that is, working from the logic of Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative- accept no maxim which you would not apply universally, AKA “do unto others as you would wish be done unto you”/ the golden rule.
The Categorical Imperative is usually applied to individuals, but in this case we’re looking at whole species. No species of a world could abide by another species that predates on them in such a fashion. For the very same reason that we probably wouldn’t think it’s evil if buffaloes tried to coordinate a total eradication of lions from their territory in order to be free from predation, for the same reason why we don’t see it as evil when wolves try to push off (or “extirpate”) all coyotes from their hunting grounds so they don’t need to compete with them for food (although that example is slightly different, I suppose), if there is a built in reason why these ‘elves’ *must* predate on ‘orcs’ just to survive, then I would argue that it’s justified for these ‘orcs’ to wage a genocidal total war with the aim of killing every single last ‘elf’ on their planet.
I mean, this is the same reason why heroes in our world are justified in slaying monsters right? The monsters are understood to be rampaging, *mindless* creatures…
I mean, in Middle Earth, the Fellowship never had any qualms about slaying Middle-Earth orcs and cutting them down, one after another, right?
But… weren’t the orcs clearly intelligent?
Grishnakh and Ugluk have speaking roles. They not only speak language, they speak *their own language*. Meaning that they have their own culture…
**The case against genocide:**
So doesn’t the equation change if the species in question was intelligent?
First, I’m going to use a different example from the mosquitos: apex predators. Lions, jaguars, eagles, tigers… we all agree that these animals, even though they rely on the predation of other animals for their survival, *do* fulfil an ecological niche. If apex predators did not eat the animals they ate, then the animals that they eat would overpopulate, which would then devastate the resources which *those* animals rely on. If there are too many rabbits, then they will eat all the grass, and once there is no grass, the rabbits will starve and their population will plummet, possibly to extinction. In effect, the wolf that eats the rabbit *serves a function*\- pruning the population, which keeps the rabbits ‘healthy’ themselves, in a weird way.
But.
How does removing wombs serve that function?
That being said, I’m now going to use a *consequentialist* *view* for justifying the survival of the ‘elves’.
If the ‘elves’ are intelligent, then they must have their own culture. What if the ‘elves’ sing beautiful songs? Write beautiful poetry? It’s not their fault that they must rely on this process for the very survival of their species- it is, for them, a necessity. What if the ‘elves’ innovate great advances in sciences, medicines, and magic? Would it not be, in and of itself, a moral good for the ‘elves’ to survive, to preserve their legacy?
What makes an ‘orc’ life inherently more ‘good’ than an ‘elf’ life? From the ‘orc’ perspective, yes, they see the ‘elves’ as predatory, and therefore from that perspective it’s justifiable for the ‘orcs’ to wage genocidal war against the ‘elves’. But from the ‘elf’ perspective, they’re simply defending their own right to live.
And couldn’t there be a peaceful way to do this?
What if the ‘womb harvesting’ was consensual? What if it was conducted through a means of trade? Let’s say that the ‘elves’ were incredibly wealthy. They could share this wealth with the ‘orcs’ in exchange for ‘orc’ women *voluntarily* donating their wombs to the ‘elves’. In this case, no one’s rights are being infringed upon, and the survival of both species continues.
So that’s how I see it. To be honest, I can’t give you a definitive answer either way. It’s still a problem I’m struggling with. But… what do you think?
**Are these ‘orcs’ justified in waging a total genocidal war against these ‘elves’?**
Also:
**1. How are the relationships between your races in your worldbuilding constructed?**
**2. If there** ***is*** **a predatory relationship between races in your worldbuilding… how do you justify a war, if both races are intelligent? What kind of logic do your MCs use to wage total war? Or can genocide** ***simply not be justified at all, no matter what the relationship between your races in your world?*** **If so, why?**
**3. And what happens when there** ***is no*** **predatory relationship by necessity, at all? What happens when… the ‘elves’ just want to kill the ‘orcs’, and the ‘orcs’ just want to kill the ‘elves’? I mean, after all, that kind of thing… happens a lot in our world. What kind of justifications for total war have you used in your own worldbuilding?**
Would love to hear your thoughts, r/worldbuilding.