RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/worldbuilding • … • u/Vanitas_Daemon

Coercive labor and its relationship to the state

Everyone likes to talk about slavery as a trope they don't like, but what I don't see is the reconciliation of that sentiment with the necessity of coercive forms of labor commensurate with statehood.

I think part of the root of this issue is that growing up, we're presented with a rather simplistic and innocent view that a state is simply a rule-making body, i.e. a government, which creates and enforces laws and maintains some degree of order over a population and territory--which isn't entirely wrong, but it fails to capture what allows for the ability to govern. Max Weber, on the other hand, recognized by many as the founder of sociology, defines the state as "a human community which successfully claims the *monopoly on the legitimate use of force* within a given territory", and it's this definition that I want to use as a lens for this post.

For the record, I'm against slavery in all its various forms, historical and present-day. And I also agree with those of you who will say that depictions of slavery often push specific supremacist and abusive fantasies held by the author. But there's a really concerning contradiction that I see when it comes to the depiction of slavery in media (really, of any kind) in that, for some reason, while most people (understandably) despise slavery and oppose it, the same people are otherwise perfectly fine with the existence of state polities which are (almost always), to varying degrees, hierarchical, centralized, and stratified, particularly in fantasy.

Few people ever really stop to consider that states across time and space, since the advent of the Uruk period in Mesopotamia, have consistently depended upon the ability to extract resources from the populations over which they ruled via coercive impositions of labor. We see this in ancient China from the Zhou Dynasty onwards *at the latest*, in South America from the time of the Wari Empire onwards, and in India since at least the *Mahajanapada* city-states, to name a few recognizable examples. Even classical era civilizations like the ancient Greeks and Romans, and later states like the various Islamic caliphates and emirates and sultanates or the Mongol Empire, and even modern states, like the USSR, the USA (prison labor), France (Francafrique), etc., all show this same pattern of dependence on extracting the fruits of labor coerced from subjugated populations.

I would go so far as to argue that you definitionally cannot have a state polity without coercion of labor according to the definition given by Weber used above. After all, to create and then extract a surplus of some product of labor from a population, you must first have the ability to exert power and control over that population, which directly stems from the monopoly on legitimate violence.

How do you reconcile the use of the aesthetic of a class of systems of social organization which at their root depend upon the coercion of labor from a subjugate population with a blanket opposition to depictions of slavery?

EDIT: To further explain my gripe with this whole state of affairs, I'm going to quote u/Generalitary's response to my question:

>I think one of the major appeals of fantasy is that it can potentially eliminate the root causes of endemic stratification. Maybe magic can provide enough food and other resources for everyone to live securely. Maybe it can help people coordinate well enough that a ruling class becomes unnecessary. In that context, a faction that wants to rule over people by force becomes even more evil through its even greater lack of self-justification.

>Which makes it sad that in most fantasy settings we default to a pseudo-feudal system where an elite class rules over the general populace, often supported by some magical practice that seems to enforce their right to rule. I personally find this approach to worldbuilding just as dissatisfying as one where slavery is rife, but a lot more insidious. If there is magic but still kings, is there much value to the magic?

— 0