RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/worldbuilding • … • u/Jinnkx

How would "natural" piercings work?

**TLDR: Metal doesn't make sense, Bone MIGHT work but doesn't make sense, and twigs/thorn injuries are too common.**

I don't know if anyone who saw my last post here would remember me, but for context I am a big Warrior Cats fan. I am writing an alternate universe WC "fan-book" that is MUCH more adult centered. It has different gods/goddesses, a somewhat different naming system, different herbs and ranks, takes place a whole different world that isn't earth (...obviously), and has actual body mods and rituals.

In my world loners, especially those who take pride in their estrangement from clans and sub-clans, have prominent ear/facial piercings. Its seen as a symbol of pride in your way of life, because the clans are too worried about them being used against them in battle (claws being caught or teeth getting stuck. Or the piercing getting ripped out intentionally) ((it also shows that loners have a much more fearless way of life and are willing to take that risk because they don't have family to stay alive for, 90% of the time)), this also means the clans have a lower societal view of cats who have them. I'm using them to show how my main character, who is currently in a clan, still deeply desires to be a loner despite the hardships she's experienced first hand, and how the other cats would understand that having them makes her 'other'.

The issue I'm having is that....they're cats. In any other fantasy setting one could see how having metal ear piercings would be seen as normal. Because of course any human-like society would know how to work metal to some degree or have magic to do it for them.... but cats can't do that though, and there is no harnessed "magic" in that sense in this universe. Yes, the reader might interpret the miracles performed by their Goddess as being "magic" but the clans themselves cannot harness that, and metal would serve no other purpose to the cats. **The clans do not use metal.** Having the Goddess favorite the significantly fewer number of loners and give them *super special metal bending abilities* sounds way too juvenile. I don't want to shell in a concept for their goddess that is in any other sense...useless.

The obvious alternative would be twigs, but I just can't see the effect being the same. Especially because twigs and thorn injuries are common, ESPECIALLY to the ears. Having a piercing using them would hold less significance because logically, anyone could have the same thing happen accidentally. Metal piercings would HAVE to be intentional, and make having one much more significant. Bones could work, but I'm curious if anyone has better ideas than that, because it feels a little brutal lol. And because having bones shaped in the perfect shape of a septum, or brow piecing, or whatnot feels very coincidental (especially when you consider that the cats don't have access to chemicals to soften the bone to shape it in a realistic way)

I know some people might argue that "well its a fantasy world. You don't have to have an explanation for everything that happens" and while I can appreciate this in any other sense, *I* the writer, dislike not having a readily available answer for something I myself have questions about. If its something a reader might catch on the off-chance this actually takes off, that's one thing, but for me to not have the answer to a question I'M asking....it just feels like lazy writing. Especially since its a major design for several characters that will be interacted with. It will be at the forefront of readers minds when they meet a loner. Or meet the other main characters. I also really don't want this to lean into the "woo woo fantasy" genre. I *want* it to be understandable for the reader. I want common questions to be answered.

— 0