Discussion: What would it take to interest players in evergreen raiding?
TLDR: What would it take to make it worth it to YOU as a player to run (properly) scaled old raids?
Something's bothered me in WoW since TBC and only grew more annoying as the years have gone by is how much content becomes completely obsolete. Blizz has added pets to old raids but that's not quite what this post is about.
I fondly remember some old raids, like throne of thunder, ulduar, and I have a special soft spot for all of T11 and Black Rock foundry. I can't really ever DO those again outside classic era and that's an entire other games worth of grind to do. I didn't play during shadow lands but I understand they DID rescale one of the early raids at one point to be worth running later? Well, what if they did this with black wing descent? Siege of orgrimmar? Ice rown citadel? You and your raids progging old raids, scaled properly (I know, blizzard has a piss poor track record of this).
What would it take to make this worth doing and fun for you? A meta achievement for clearing all of an expansions raids scaled? Exclusive mounts, pets, gear recolors, etc? Looking at other MMOs, FF14s ultimate tier of fights matches this fairly well, difficult fights with purely cosmetic rewards, bragging rights, and the enjoyment of the prog. Obviously some raids would be piss easy by comparison, like pretty much all of classic, but look at the current time walking raids and how they just fall over and tell me that's not just sad.
Edit: I don't think the raid should have any gear attached to it. It would compete with current raid tiers as a result, and become another weekly checklist to do. Players should want to do it for the fun or the cosmetic rewards and bragging rights, NOT for more gear.