RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/wow • … • u/_Llopis_

Here's the actual math on bonus rolls from the vault

**TL;DR:** People's intuitions about the superiority of bonus rolls are generally correct, but you should _sometimes_ take an item from the vault. It depends on the size of the loot pool versus how many items you need.

---

I wanted to know the actual math behind the vault and bonus rolls, so I came up with a simple formula to measure how many weeks it would take, on average, to get all you want from a boss or dungeon with vault items and bonus rolls:

v+n(p+1)/(n+1)

v is the number of items taken from the vault (usually 1, unless you're planning long-term), p is the number of items left in the boss's or dungeon's loot pool, and n is the number of items you still need from the boss or dungeon.

If you need 2 items from an 8-item pool, and you take one from the vault, it would take you 5.5 weeks to get what you need. If you only go with bonus rolls, it would take 6 weeks. In this case, taking the item from the vault is the higher-probability play.

But if you need 4 items from an 8-item pool, the vault item is the lower-probability play. If you take an item from the vault, you would need 7.75 weeks, on average, to get what you need. With just bonus rolls, it's 7.2.

Another way to look at it: For the vault item to be worth it, p+1 must be greater than n(n+1). If that's true, take the vault item. If it's not, take the bonus roll.

Anyway, this is what Blizzard's failure to remove vault items from the loot pool has driven me to do.

— 0