Addons not synching between "All" Characters

Is this happening to anyone else? If I'm on Toon A using the Addon Manager with the "All" dropdown selected and I check/uncheck a bunch of different addons, when I go to Toon B and Toon C, etc., none of the addons I selected on Toon A under the "All" dopdown get carried over to the other toons. I know it isn't a huge deal but with 10 alts it's very tedious going through 30 different addons on each of them to disable certain ones. Thanks