Removing Raid Attunements Has Me Worried About Forever Endgame
First off, I am not a Classic Andy, and have no desire for Forever to perfectly preserve the Classic experience. I WANT Forever to take what was great about Classic and remaster and expand on it in ways that are true to the original design. I love the new additions like class rebalancing and profession upgrades, and camping is a step in the right direction. I started at launch and I MT'd through MC, BWL, and AQ (never was good enough for vanilla Naxx), so I'm exactly the target audience when the devs describe "classic players with lapsed accounts who didn't like where retail ended up."
I think removing raid attunements is a mistake, and it makes me worried about the design direction for endgame. Were the original raid attunements a massive pain, especially for Onyxia? Yes. Did they keep people out of raids who wanted to run them? Yes. But I think despite the downsides, what they did do was important.
The Onyxia attunement quest was massive and probably way too much work for a fairly simple raid. But over the course of the quest chain, it had you engage with content all across the world. You had to do quests for major lore characters, you had to run difficult dungeons that actually tested your ability to succeed in the raids, and you uncovered a secret plot that changed the state of Stormwind itself.
It was probably overkill, but an important factor was that it was impossible to do solo. If your guild wanted to run Onyxia, you had to make an effort together to get everyone attuned. We were doing regular dungeon runs for weeks to get guild members attuned, and it was a rewarding group effort that ended with us all getting to run the raid together. If a new member joined our guild, we would organize dungeon runs to get them attuned. It was the best of what WoW had to offer, and it's exactly what I would like to see more of in Forever.
The attunements got easier over time as more raids were released, and eventually went away completely because Blizzard wanted people to hurry up and consume their content. This is the direction I hope Forever doesn't go, and I'm worried the 5-man dungeons are going to get ignored and skipped entirely because everyone can just jump into a 10-man raid and start getting epics as soon as they hit level 60.
I don't want raid attunements to remain because I want to "keep casuals out of raiding" or anything like that - in fact, I hope raiding is a little easier than it was in vanilla so that more people can experience it. But I think raid attunements, especially the ones that span continent-wide quest chains and require grouping, make the world feel more alive and interconnected, instead of just a hub of portals that lead to loot dispensers.
In fact, I hope they preserve attunements for the 5-man dungeons too. Having to engage with the quests in the world to unlock the privilege of running the dungeons makes it feel like you actually earned something instead of just jumping in queue for the loot treadmill like retail.
I hope the dev team reconsiders attunements, even if it's in a less... grueling form.
EDIT: Some people have floated the possibility that Blizz meant only the newly added raids will not have attunements, and the old raid attunements will remain. Which if true, is still a little disappointing because that's just going to encourage people to immediately jump into the new raids and ignore the legacy raids entirely.
Maybe the new raids are going to be geared around tier 0.5, on par with the max level dungeons, so players will be able to gear up for the tier 1 raids either through 5-man dungeons or 10/20-man raids. That would be cool I guess, but I have a hard time believing Blizzard would design a whole new set of raids that won't be the most rewarding content to run.