RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/wowforever • … • u/Knaprig

Is white hit damage handcuffing the WoWF melee design space?

tl;dr: Devs say they can't give melees more resources or buttons because they deal too much damage from autos already. This is silly.

After listening to the latest podcast episode as a PvE Rogue enjoyer who has played wow since Vanilla, their discussions relating to the melee class design really had me split. They were talking about how warriors and rogues as a baseline in Vanilla deal a lot of white hit damage, and contrasting that to modern wow where you click an ability every GCD and white hit damage is negligible, framing that as a bad thing and too hectic.

I agree!

The core ideas that in a Classic dps rotation you want a decent amount of downtime and waiting, both in order to make individual button presses to feel impactful, and to be "allowed" to weave in utility, is awesome and part of why I love classic. But the buttons can't be impactful if auto swing damage is too high.

They seemed to have a strange hard-line stance on shifting damage away from white hits into yellow hits. A combat rogue's damage breakdown in TBC (which has more energy regen/resources than in Forever!) is 70% white hits, 25% sinister strike, 3% poison damage, and less than 1% each rupture and eviscerate; they only get enough combo points to use two separate maintenance finishing moves (SnD and Expose Armour). The way WoWF looks right now it will be very similar, with perhaps some more damage from poisons since they seem to be buffed.

And the devs said that they tried giving rogues and warriors more resources, and whoops they deal too much damage and they "needed to nerf their ability damage-per-click to the ground" to compensate...without addressing the elephant in the room being auto attacks eating up the majority of their damage budget.

I'm not asking for white hits to be trivial like in Cataclysm and onwards, especially at lower levels, but surely there's a middle ground to be had where we can drop white hit damage slightly to use a bit more of our kit and allowing the devs more wiggle room with their class design space? An assassination rogue has access to Venom, Expose Armour, Slice and Dice, Rupture, and Eviscerate. It just feels depressing having this nice set of 5 finishers with different durations and priorities depending on situation, and then being given so few resources that we'll only really get to use two or three of them, depending on crit chance.

— 0