WoW Forever and Lore: A Revisit, not a Rewrite
**TLDR:** *WoW Forever can be compelling without completely rewriting Warcraft lore. Blizzard has a chance to correct things they deem missteps. They can tell stories that happen simultaneous to the established Warcraft canon. They don't need to create an "alternate universe" that will be rendered irrelevant once Forever is no longer supported or a "WoW2" is released. I've become hopeful that this will be their approach, as opposed to rewriting stories that have been previously told.*
Hi everyone!
I’ve been wondering a lot about how WoW Forever intends to handle lore. We have heard this referenced as an “alternate timeline” and the stated goal of “expanding stories in areas that already existed.”
At first I thought this would be an entirely parallel universe, and perhaps that is the case. However, the more I have thought about it, the more I think that there is an opportunity to approach WoW Forever’s story in a really unique way that stays true to the established Warcraft lore.
If ever there is WoW sequel, it would be a shame for the stories told in Forever to cease to exist. To be non-canon. Or alternatively, to scrap retail if Forever seems to become a favorite (unlikely). One way or another, one game’s fanbase is going to be bummed.
So why not both?
**Different Path, Same Destination**
The primary suggestion here is that WoW Forever’s story, wherever it takes us, does not alter the major story-beats established in WoW’s nearly 22 year history. Illidan and Arthas are defeated. Deathwing shatters the world. The Horde experiences tumult among the Warchiefs. What they can do is tell parallel stories, or retell the existing stories in new ways that remain more or less accurate to the world they’ve built while improving upon decisions or approaches to the story they may now view as mistakes.
We have the same starting point, but now we have 22 years of hindsight. I strongly suspect that there are events that have occurred since WoW launched that were thought up well after preceding events took place, or stories revisited in clunky manners because the realities of running an MMO impacted the narrative.
The most obvious example I can point to here is Naxxramas. In retail, Naxx was launched at the end of Vanilla. Very few people got to experience this great raid because BC launched shortly after. Many guilds were still farming BWL / AQ when BC came out, rendering Naxxramus relatively underutilized. The resulting lore decisions were a bit silly. Kel’thuzad is killed. His phylactery is lost. He is revived, as well as every other boss in Naxx. Naxx relocated to Northerend. Kel’thuzad and other bosses are killed again, in the exact same manner.
WoW Forever can smooth out this narrative without reinventing the Warcraft story. Naxx can still invade the Plaguelands, and can also still be the first step in the battle against Arthas. Perhaps it is an unexpected assault that revitalized the dormant Lich King threat. Kel’thuzad can just die once. The raid never needs to relocate, and people can enjoy it as intended for years to come. The story of Kel’thuzad, and his importance to preparing for Arthas, never change. It’s just cleaner now – benefiting from no expansion rendering it obsolete, and years of hindsight to ensure a better story.
**Playing Alternate Roles**
The other obvious thing that could happen as the Warcraft story plays out is that players have a chance to play different roles. Burning Crusade was the first major expansion, and we all rushed through the Dark Portal to take on Illidan. But what happened back on Azeroth? What did the heroes who remained behind have to face?
There is no reason that content can’t be released set during BC that references the events happening on the other side of the Dark Portal that we AREN’T seeing. The stated goal is for us to stay in Azeroth. We can do that, and the story of BC can still happen. Maybe someone tried to close the Portal from the Azeroth side, stranding our heroes and that portal-closer needs to be stopped. Perhaps there is a Centaur uprising on Kalimdor and so many of those who would normally address such an issue are gone. The story in Outland can happen, and we can hear about it via Quest text and NPCs, while tending to the threats back "home".
Lastly, tying back into my idea of improving the lore with the benefit of hindsight, but reaching the same destination, let’s talk about a major character like Illidan. In Warcraft lore, Illidan is killed at the Black Temple. His body is brought back to the Vault of the Wardens. He is revived by Gul’dan. He is eventually brought back. I dunno, it seems clunky. Call me crazy but I suspect if the lore of Legion was planned at the time of BC Illidan never would have been “killed”, perhaps just captured. Such a small tweak can be corrected in this remake. And if they still want us as Forever players to participate, maybe the “raid” on Azeroth is participating in the transport of Illidan from the Portal to the Vault of Wardens, and there are groups that try and stop us and Maiev. We still participate in the story, just a different perspective.
**No Parallel Universe**
To close, I think the big thing I hope is that whatever story is told in WoW Forever isn’t rendered obsolete in the future. Perhaps the best way to do this is to ensure that whatever major plot beats we experience, they jive with existing canon.
I think it can be done in a way that’s interesting. I think that they can improve on “mistakes” that have been made due to release timing or simple hindsight, while still having the game reach the same “endpoints”. There are plenty new stories to tell, or old stories to improve. Vol’jin comes to mind here, so many players think he was done dirty and had an anti-climatic death. Well… we can revisit that. He can be given a proper send off. Tweaked story, but same destination.
I think we can still participate meaningfully in the world-shattering threats Azeroth has faced without having to leave the planet (if that is indeed the stated goal).
Curious if anyone has any other thoughts or examples, or if people hope I’m dead wrong and we get a complete re-write.