Ideas for potential horizontal progression systems
Putting aside whether WoW Forever is meant to be a horizontal game or not, I think it would be good if the devs could work in ways to keep content relevant in the long term even if player power isn't hard capped. There's ways I think a game like WoW could implement these systems while still offering upgrades that feel good.
The real purpose of horizontal systems isn't so much to keep players locked to one power level forever, but rather to slow down the process of power creep enough such that old content doesn't become dead and irrelevant, at least not fast enough for it to really matter. To that end, rather than locking in on any one strategy, they should be looking to implement as many different kinds of endgame progression systems as possible. Here's some things I think they could try:
- Chase items, rare items that drop from bosses that are better than other loot and stay meta far into the future, so players are encouraged to keep running older things. I believe this is something they've said they're already planning.
- Adding new items and bosses to older areas and instances.
- Items that require running old content to access or enable them. e.g. a new tier might drop a crafting recipe for an upgrade, which requires materials from an earlier tier. Or you could have gear that requires an older piece of gear as a base. Or you could have item drops that then need to be further upgraded or "attuned" via grinds or quests that involve going back into old content (maybe even requiring you to use the gear itself).
- Cosmetics. Just cool sets or prestigious rare items and mounts that people want to get even if it's not an upgrade.
- "Sidegrades" i.e. items that are upgrades but only for certain builds or in certain situations. Can include things like resist gear or bonus stats in certain biomes or vs certain enemies. I believe they've said this is also something they're planning to do. This can also include items that enable new playstyles like Shaman tank. They can't add new niches indefinitely, so this is more about increasing the number of desirable types of rewards, which slows down how quickly they have to add more power.
- Borrowed power systems WAIT LET ME FINISH. I don't mean in the WoW Retail style where eventually everything is reset and you lose your progress. But rather content with its own progression systems that are active only within that content. You get stronger in that content but can't take that power out into other content. So rather than one giant vertical ladder that keeps going up until it eventually gets broken and replaced, you instead have multiple smaller separate vertical ladders each of which you progress separately. Since the content never becomes irrelevant, your progress in these systems is never "lost". Also, these systems could also allow you to earn *small* permanent boosts that work outside the system so they also have minor value for all content, without creating huge power disparities and while also still allowing players to get the nice feeling of substantial power boosts inside the closed system.
- New gameplay formats. Retail has things like pet battles and housing and while maybe these don't fit Forever, they are examples of other ways to play the game that allow for more variety in rewards that aren't just pure power. Perhaps Forever could add new ways to use professions, like minigames that players can compete in, with their own gear and stats.
- Randomized gear rewards i.e. gear drops with random stats and properties. Think something like Monster Hunter's talisman appraisal system. Getting a decent enough item is easy, but getting "the god roll" is like one in a million, so there's always the hope of getting something better. Of course this would not apply to all gear, probably only one slot would have items that do this, if they did something like this at all.
- Timed bonus incentives to return to old content. Like maybe people aren't running some of these old dungeons/raids very much anymore, so there could be weekly rotating bonuses that increases drop chances for the best loot, more loot, or gives extra rewards for completion that can be put towards current gear.
- Extra combat/power systems that they can add more options to without just increasing vertical power. For example, they could add something like Retail's Hero talents, except instead of just getting each tree automatically, you have to unlock it at endgame and then progress it individually point by point by running content or completing quests and class-specific objectives. Once you've unlocked a tree and its points you can swap it out with any others you have unlocked. By adding new trees and/or systems they can add more options and things to progress without just directly increasing power.
Again, the ideal scenario is where they use a combination of ALL these kinds of ideas and systems rather than just relying on any one strategy. With this I think they can offer satisfying progression while keeping old content relevant and limiting power creep enough that players don't feel like their progress is nullified, or that they are left too far behind if they are away from the game for a long time.