What's the best compliment you received as a writer?
I start:
1. Characterisation, your characters are relatable, grounded in their place and situation and they act consistently with their character. I felt a connection with Clementine, and you shows different aspects of her character, her toughness and resilience, but also her caring and compassionate side. Having well rounded characters is the key to connecting with them as a reader, and you executed that really well. 2. Your writing style is relatively fast paced, which I enjoy a lot. Your later pieces show that you are more confident in your authorial voice, which is a tricky thing to develop and is not something you can really teach. 3. You have a natural ability one a scene level. You instinctively know where to both start and end a scene. A good rule of thumb is for a narrator to arrive at the party late and leave early, and you do that impeccably. 4. You created some evocative scenes. The settings were fresh and immersive, and the characters interacted with each other in a way that felt relatable, but still in keeping with the world around them. 5. The overall sense I get from your writing is that you have a natural storytelling ability, there is a strong sense of authorial voice. The scenes is well structured in terms of plot, characterisation, progression.
This was when I sent a collection of five short stories written over the course of my two years of writing professionally to a local beta reader for the first time.