RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/writers • … • u/Strugglingwriter10

Query Letter Critique

Right, this is the second book I queried after querying an internal stakes romance last year that crashed and burned.

I was sure that this second stab at the querying trenches was going to be it and I’d at least get some full requests. Fast forward 8 weeks and I’ve only had rejections. I’m hoping (praying) that you guys might be able to tell me if my query sucks or my writing so I can fix it and send out to more agents or completely abandon and start a new project….

Query letter:

Dear Agent name,

I am seeking representation for THE SAFEHOUSE, a 68,000 word romance with crime/thriller elements. It’s a lyrical second chance romance full of unspoken tension, stakes that keep escalating and a brown kitten called Pixel that ties them together. It is for readers that enjoy the writing style of Carley Fortune, but need something a little darker as seen in Twisted Games by Ana Huang. It has similar vibes to the hit action Netflix Series, The Night Agent.

Colby Mae McCall is on her first MI5 assignment, close to arresting a major player in Bristol’s drug enterprise. After three months undercover, she’s successfully lifted an encrypted USB, which she’s sure will be the proof they need to bring down the whole gang. Everything is going perfectly until she bumps into her ex-boyfriend, Rhys Otto Briar. He’s the one she never got over. He’s the reason she joined MI5.

Rhys is eager to catch up and unknowingly blows Colby’s cover, forcing her to arrest her target before the USB has been decrypted. This has grave consequences: Colby’s flat is broken into, and Rhys’s is petrol bombed. Left with no other choice, they both run and hide in a safehouse.

During their stay, Colby attempts to keep Rhys at arm's length, convinced that that is the safest way to look after her heart. But when her target is released, and she starts to feel watched, her walls quickly begin to crack, letting little pieces of Rhys in again.

Just as they get comfortable around each other again, they make a shocking USB discovery that sends them both home and straight into a sting operation. Ultimately, Colby is faced with two options: save Rhys or make the arrest.

Growing up, I either had my head stuck in a book or was bribing my best friend to illustrate my crazy stories about ballet teachers (I hated those classes!). The Safehouse would be my debut novel.

Thank you so much for considering my work,

Sincerely,

Gemma McLaren (she/her)

First 300 words:

This little pub is the perfect place to go with your boyfriend. The brown leather seats, teal bar and shiny gold beer pumps are cosy, romantic, sensual. My eyes scan my surroundings methodically. Two of the couples here are on first or second dates.

In the corner, a Ralph Lauren shirt holds hands with a red dress. If I concentrate, I can lip read exactly what he’s saying - ‘how long were you in Spain for’, ‘what do you do for work’, ‘your dog is so cute’. All standard first date questions. Ones I’ve been asked myself.

Further down the bar, a whiskey drinker feels up a wine lady's leg, and whispers sweet phrases in her ear softly like a candle in a dark room - ‘you look amazing’, ‘your skin is so soft’, ‘I love your eyes’. Second date sexual tension barrels off them.

I refocus on the man in front of me, catching the last part of his story, “And then, I took a knuckle duster and punched him so hard his eye sockets broke. Bastard literally pissed himself, it was disgusting. I had to get my Armani suit dry cleaned.” Gabriel tells me while he picks dust off his blue Tom Ford jacket. The wool alone probably costs more than two months’ rent on my Clifton apartment. His custom tailoring bumps it up another three.

I trail my finger around the rim of my glass, cross my legs and purr, “Oh. It all sounds so dangerous,” like an airhead, because that’s what he wants.

“It is.” Gabriel feigns nonchalance at the praise, but I know deep down it feeds his soul, “You have to uphold an image. People hear the name Gabriel Pagan and vomit; they're so scared.”

They don’t, but I humour him anyway. Nodding and batting my eyes like a deer in cartoons, I say, “All the girls at the strip club were terrified of you.”

— 0