RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/writers • … • u/Old_Introduction7236

Don't Bother Asking for Criticism if You're Just Going to Argue

I've seen an increase (in this and other writing subs) in the amount of requests for feedback I see followed by the the author criticizing the feedback.

If you want your writing critiqued, then TAKE THE CRITICISM. Take it with a grain of salt, sure, but do consider that someone took the time to read your request, formulate coherent thoughts on the construction and effect of your writing and the feeling it may have evoked, and then took the additional time to offer up a critique, in the good faith that you WANTED the information that you asked for and would at least ATTEMPT to put it to use.

Telling me that my criticism is bad or invalid just tells me that I wasted my time responding to your request and that I shouldn't bother wasting any more of my time with you.

It also tells the other writers in the sub as well. So...

You may wish to consider whether or not you truly want your writing evaluated or criticized before you make the request. Then having made it, try accepting what you receive with some humility rather than firing back with a critique of the criticism.

You either want the feedback or you don't. Don't waste my time.

Edit:

It has been pointed out by several individuals that my own critiquing method stands to be improved. I agree with that assessment, but it isn't the point of this discussion. The fact remains that the person doing the reviewing isn't the one who is asking for the critique; those are separate concerns. If the ask and answer are both done in good faith, then the person asking should respect the time and effort put forth by the person offering the feedback. Simple as.

— 0