RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/writingcirclejerk • … • u/USSPalomar

When was the last original story published?

It's a well-known maxim in the writing community that everything has already been done before--there's no such thing as a truly original story in modern fiction. However, we can clearly see that animals without language lack the ability to tell stories. This suggest that there was a point in time after the evolution of language when certain stories had *not* *yet* been "done before", implying the existence of a Last Original Story (LOS) that was the final new use of language before all possibilities were exhausted.

I intend to write my PhD thesis on the topic of identifying the LOS. My application to Harvard got rejected, but I figure that if I press the "publish" button on KDP while standing somewhere on the Harvard campus, I can obliquely refer to "the thesis I published while at Harvard" to get clout, babes, and paid guest speaker invitations to anthropology conferences.

But like anyone seriously involved in the craft of writing, I don't want to do all the work myself, so I'm partially outsourcing to internet schlubs so that they can provide external validation and explanations of how to execute my ideas (I'm more of an ideas guy, honestly). So I'd like you all to tell me that the following thought process is correct, and suggest any peer-reviewed sources you can think of that would back it up.

We can zero in on the approximate era the LOS was published in by bracketing it with dates of known originality. Western Civilization (and thus literature) was invented by the Roman Empire, and thus the LOS cannot logically predate 27 BC. For an upper limit, we note that Campbell's *The Hero with a Thousand Faces* was published in 1949, and all stories told since then have been reiterations of the Hero's Journey (though some works prior to 1949 were also Hero's Journey, muddling this date).

27BC - 1949AD is thus the maximum, incontrovertible time span in which the LOS must have been published. Narrowing it down further than that relies more on my own speculation, which will make up the bulk of the thesis.

Many stories of the 1800s and early 1900s relied on Biblical allegory; we thus contend that the contents of the Bible are entirely original and not based on any previous work, since otherwise we wouldn't call it "Biblical allegory", we'd call it allegory of whatever hypothetical text preceded the bible. Considering the estimated date of the most recent book of the New Testament, this moves our lower limit up to around 100 AD (the Quran and Book of Mormon don't count; no creative or intellectual developments have ever come out of the Middle East, and Joseph Smith received his revelations from a time-travelling Orson Scott Card, whose writing is strictly Hero's Journey due to his native timeframe).

However, I propose that the LOS is significantly more recent in that. In the realm of nonfiction, we can provably argue that works up until 1687 were original, since the first real derivative work was Newton's *Principia* (which was not merely a rehash of, but a complete plagiarism of Leibniz's *Nova Methodus*). Since even hobbyist fiction writers are significantly more skilled than academics, it seems ridiculous to assume that fiction would have run out of original ideas before nonfiction. Now you might counter with: "but what if the fiction writers were producing work much more quickly than nonfiction writers?" to which I reply: "when was the last time you saw a hobbyist writer finish anything?"

This brings us up to the 1700s, which, as you may recall, were the origins of the Industrial Revolution. And with the Industrial Revolution came the most important development in the history of literature: Young Adult Fiction. Prior to 1833, when Britain outlawed child labor in factories, all fiction was written for adults. With children now having free time, and literacy rates rising, a new market opened up which necessitated the invention of new stories to appeal to youngsters. A German philologist named Karl Morgenstern actually predicted the development of this market, coining the term *Bildungsroman* in 1819 to describe a (purely theoretical, at the time) plot structure in which a hot clumsy girl who isn't like other girls but is just like you gets fought over by two shirtless white guys and ultimately ascends to a position of power via magical or violent means. One of the earliest examples of this is *Wuthering Heights* by Charlotte Bronte, which cemented the archetypical YA plot structure that would survive throughout the 19th, 20th, and early 21st centuries.

But Bronte was a Brit, and we all know that true invention comes from the United States of America, so it's only logical that some American author would perfect the art of YA. Now you might think that it would be from someone famous like Mark Twain, but keep in mind that his first story was commissioned by Artemus Ward, a prototypical stand-up comedian, thus destroying any credibility to the claim that it had original material.

Instead, it was Horatio Alger who furthered the genre, creating a rags-to-riches story based on the Protestant work ethic, whereas its most similar predecessors (like Cinderella and Genesis 37) were rooted in Old World notions of hereditary monarchy. He codified the American Dream as a plot structure, which led directly to the development of cultivation novels, LitRPG, and progression fantasy.

Thus I contend that ***Ragged Dick: or, Street Life in New York with the Boot Blacks*** **(1867)** was the first truly American novel, and thus the last truly original novel. All of literature since then has been rehashes of Alger's American plot structure, or previous European plot structures.

"But wait," you might say, "What about stories in visual media?"

And this is a very important question. Because while literature is a strictly English-language endeavor, cultures outside of the West have made useful contributions to storytelling in other forms.

That's right. I'm talking about anime. Compared to stale, over-trodden prose fiction, anime is full of unique and inventive ideas, which jumps the minimum date of the LOS forward by nearly 100 years to 1963, when *Astro Boy* first aired on TV.

The question now becomes: when was the last original anime?

My semi-controversial (and startlingly recent) answer is **November 30th, 2007**, when Nickelodeon aired the 2-parter **"The Day of the Black Sun"** of *Avatar: The Last Airbender*. This episode sees the culmination of Zuko's "redemption arc", a type of character development that no one had ever tried before. While the overall structure of the episode mirrors the pre-"dark night of the soul" twist codified by Campbell and popularized by *The Empire Strikes Back*, I would argue that the inclusion of Zuko confronting his father to reject the family's imperial expectations differentiates it sufficiently that we can label it (and the series as a whole) as truly original.

So what do you think? Do my arguments hold water? If you think they do, validate me. If you think they don't, post your own theories so that I can shoot them down, call you a troll, and report you to the mods for not engaging discussion in a civil manner. Also, if you have any suggestions on how to start writing (like what my opening paragraph should be) please tell me in the comments.

— 0