Failure modes of bindings
I've been pondering the relative strengths and weaknesses of different bindings. This question comes in particular which binding to use when going off the tracks into ungroomed terrain, where control and strength become more important than weight and speed.
The controllability under normal conditions seems to be a function of size, 3-pin 75mm bindings have more width than a NNN-BC magnum binding at 67mm, which in turn have more width area than Turnamic/NNN. So just by being bigger, they will provide more leverage, and thus allow for more control in steeper or gnarlier terrain.
But apart from the nominal performance, what risks do the bindings carry, in particular in off-track usage? How do they fail? Does the "beefiness" bring any extra value other than more leverage?
Failure modes that I saw reports of include
* NNN/Turnamic: Freezing up, toe bar separating from shoe * NNN-BC: Freezing up, toe bar separating from shoe, ski breaking around the screw points * 3-pin: Holes in boots ripping out, ski breaking around the screw points
On the face of it, it seems like using the smallest binding that gets the job done on the terrain would be fine. In particular, since NNN/Turnamic are bonded instead of screwed to the ski, they may be advantageous on relatively mild terrain, since they preserve the integrity of the ski, and skis being weakened is a non-issue.
Maybe there's some experiments on maximum force to failure on each binding, or some experience from rentals and their failure modes?