RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/xxfitness • … • u/some__random

1lb/week doesn't always match the scale

[My TDEE Spreadsheet](https://imgur.com/a/vse8gof)

I've been cutting calories since January 1st and weighing myself almost every day since Jan 11th. At first I was losing consistently, but then I completely stalled in February, starting at 179lbs and ending at 179.8lbs. This was super discouraging because I knew that I was being disciplined with weighing food, tracking calories, I don't snack or binge, and I generally eat clean with lots of protein.

Well, since February 28th I'm suddenly down 4lbs. Yeah, this is March 6th. That's 4lbs in one week.

It seems my weight fluctuates a hell of a lot. I wasn't feeling bloated but I'm assuming that this was water weight that was masking the fat loss still happening behind the scenes. My scale did measure a BF% decrease in February even though weight stayed the same.

My average calories since January 11th has been 1542/day (although I wasn't eating much to begin with, recently it's been more like 1650) and I've now lost 9lbs, maybe more since January 1st since I hadn't weighed myself before then and I'm sure I had that initial water weight drop. If that was evenly distributed it would be 1.125lbs per week and would put my TDEE at at least 2100/2200 and deficit calories at around 1600/1700.

The spreadsheet has been useful in that I can see what my calories and weight has been and how it changes, but it's been really bad at working out my TDEE and deficit calories because my weight trends just don't do what it expects and it will stay the same for some time then suddenly drop a few pounds in a couple of days or even overnight.

I just wanted to share this for anyone else who feels like they've stalled despite doing everything right. Keep the faith and keep being consistent. You're not breaking the laws of physics, your body just isn't a machine and it's not always as simple as '1lb per week' might make you expect.

— 0