RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/yakuzagames • … • u/pretzel_consumption

Yakuza 8 was an unfortunate disappointment -- and I genuinely think the series needs a hard reset at this point.

**Apologies in advance for the effortpost. I don't intend for this to be a complainathon, but would love for some genuine discussion around where the Yakuza series can go from here.**

I would describe myself as a big fan of this series. I love these games -- love the characters, the settings, the stories (even with how "balls out" stupid they can be sometimes). That said, after six main entries and a handful of spinoffs, it was all wearing thin for me -- which is why Yakuza 7, despite not being anywhere near perfect in my estimation, felt like such a breath of fresh air. I enjoyed Yokohama. I enjoyed Ichiban and his friends. I enjoyed the turn-based battle system, even though it diminished the energy and impact of boss battles. Moreover, I generally enjoyed how they treated the franchise's icons -- as side-characters and as bosses rather than as main characters, a direction I think they should have taken with Kiryu starting from Yakuza 4.

All that being said, the game still suffered from all the narrative issues that have always plagued Yakuza.

* The need to retcon in Yakuza families and characters who never appeared in the prior games * The idiotic, unnecessary twists (Mirror Face, two coin locker babies, etc.) * The "no-kill-rule/forgive everyone" philosophy and its frustrating consequences in a violent setting

For all these reasons, I was hoping that Yakuza 8 moving the primary setting out of Japan would revitalize the franchise -- and (although I'm sure this is blasphemy), I was excited that they were doing something drastic and final with Kiryu. I was ready for this series to finally pass the torch.

To my great disappointment (and what follows is my opinion, which need not be shared by the rest of this community), **Yakuza 8 failed not only as a "pass the torch" moment for the franchise -- it failed fundamentally as a story.**

**Hawaii:** Despite its potential, the Hawaii plotline is a listless mess.

* The characters arrive two weeks after Akane's disappearance, making all their investigations useless; at one point, the party literally goes to the beach to look around for clues on the ground -- a massively trafficked public beach, two weeks after the disappearance. Ichiban and his new friends spend the entire game wandering around aimlessly until they can fall ass-backwards into the plot. * The competing institutions of the Yamai Alliance, the Barracudas, and Ganzhe only have plots as deep as the chapters in which they are featured, with the Barracudas and Ganzhe literally merging together after a handful of chapters -- never becoming meaningful again from a plot perspective, only serving as muscle for Bryce/Palekana. * Lani, a human MacGuffin for most of the game, reveals that she is carrying another MacGuffin -- a pendant that supposedly marks her as the true heir to Palekana, along with a letter from Palekana's former leader. What prevents Bryce, who has literal armies of brainwashed followers at his disposal, from claiming both of these things to be fake and ignoring Lani altogether? What power does she actually have to upend anything about his evil enterprise? * The above is just one of an "infinite" number of plot holes, cut corners, and contrivances -- for example, someone questions why Akane took Lani straight into dangerous Yami territory, to which Ichiban responds that it was a smart move because Yamai is aligned against Bryce. But given that Akane had no idea that Bryce was a criminal mastermind puppeteering an artificial conflict between the Barracudas and Ganzhe, with Yamai's group as a fringe nuisance, how would she know that Yamai would be a safe bet in comparison to Bryce?

**Character Writing:**

* **Ichiban:** I get that he's supposed to be a human puppy who forgives everyone, but can we relax this shonen trope just a little? Just a little bit? Can he, as somewhat of an extension of the player, hold villains (and in some cases, like Chitose, heroes) accountable for their actions? * **Daigo, Saejima, & Majima:** Really? I get that RGG wanted to code in a boss fight with these guys, but they gave up because of a social media video? How many times do these guys (Daigo in particular) have to fumble the bag so that Kiryu can come over and physically beat some motivation and self-respect back into them? It made sense in Yakuza 2. It sort of made sense in Yakuza 4. At this point, it's just tired. * **Saeko/Romance:** The writers of this series have never known what to do with romance -- even when they stumble into passable romantic plotlines (Yakuza 2, 4), they always find a way to undo it or screw it up. I'm totally read for them to attempt an actual romance between two main characters, but they don't do that here. They treat the entire thing like a joke and separate Ichiban and Saeko for the entire game. How am I supposed to have any investment in this plotline if you don't let the two characters interact with each other, push and pull against one another, and (potentially) overcome their conflict through action rather than inaction? * **Hanawa/Daidoji:** I understand that Gaiden was written after Infinite Wealth. But let's acknowledge the real reason that Hanawa was killed off in such an unceremonious way: so that the writers could start to wiggle out of the hole that Yakuza 6 put them in and justify Kiryu's Life Links. As many on this sub have acknowledged, the Daidoji's writing is horrifically inconsistent. Are they powerful enough for Kiryu to respect as a sociopolitical organization and threat to his family's lives? Or are they a bunch of impotent doofuses who don't know their asses from their elbows? The plot oscillates between the two as needed, but it spends most of its energy supporting the latter assessment -- the least interesting of the two. * **Kiryu's Party:** If you look up any pre-release thread for this game, you will find hundreds of posts speculating who might be in Kiryu's party -- Majima? Saejima? Date? Akiyama? Daigo? Haruka??? The list goes on. I can tell you, my list didn't include Saeko or Zhao. Kiryu has no connection to these characters beyond Ichiban, as evidenced by the fact that all their Drink Links (except Seonhee's, the one bright spot here) devolve into conversations about Ichiban. If you're going to give me Kiryu's last hurrah, give it to me the right way -- with a supporting cast who actually know him and who actually have a reason to care about him and fight on his behalf.

**Kiryu & Passing The Torch:** Beyond all my frustrations with the game's narrative, my deeper concern is its handling of the "torch" of the franchise -- which is to say, the torch hasn't been passed at all. This is still Kiryu's franchise, as evidenced by the fact that the writers didn't have the gumption to actually kill him off. And that raises all kinds of questions for me. How much story does Kiryu have left to tell? How much do the other old heads (Daigo, Saejima, Majima, etc.)? Frankly, how much story does Ichiban have left to tell? He's almost fifty, he's taken down two major Yakuza organizations, a pillar of the Japanese government, and a Hawaiian cult demagogue. He's overcome all of the major trauma points of his past. He's met his mother, he's avenged his father's death. Where does he go from here? The series has dropped "Yakuza" from its name, but can it finally pen a story without them?

The more I've thought about this game, the more I've felt that this entire series needs a hard reset. Put us in a new setting with new characters -- or reboot the existing setting altogether, liberating us from the constraints imposed by the franchise's past entries and characters. Or, if all of those things are too difficult to walk away from, pull another Yakuza 7 -- give me interesting new characters with conflicts of their own, and keep the franchise's legends (including Ichiban) as minor characters supporting the new ones.

**Where do you think this franchise should go in its next installment?**

— 0