RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/youtube • … • u/ctcwired

5.1 surround processing broken for new uploads

Is it just me or does 5.1 surround sound audio never finish processing on new videos now?

On both my test channels and a larger (50K subscriber) channel I manage for my job, I can't get any of my 5.1 mixes to go through on YouTube. The 5.1 track always took several days to process (just like HDR), but even uploading the same file that did work 6 months ago now doesn't work (only gets stereo).

It had been flakey for a while, failed on occasion, and for a few months seemed to only work on one of the channels I manage but not the other. As of the last month or two it seems broken completely.

Things I've tried:

* Different containers (MOV, MKV) * Different muxer versions (older vs newer versions of mkvtoolnix) * Different codecs combinations (H.264, H.265, PCM, AAC, FLAC) * Different lengths (2 hour videos, 20 second clips) * Different resolutions/qualities (SDR, HDR, 1080p, 4K, etc) * Different mix dynamic ranges & loudnesses (various LUFS levels)

I did notice the loudness target did affect whether YouTube created a "DRC" or "stable volume" track or not, however this didn't appear to affect whether 5.1 worked or not.

I've reached out to support in several ways, they're always kind and say they'll look into it, sometimes even telling me they will try to "reprocess" the video, but it hasn't seemed to solve it.

— 0