RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/youtube • … • u/better_rabit

"why are big YouTubers not talking about age verification" and why it's better to just vocal without them

Whenever news headlines discuss another app,video game, application etc introducing age verification the same lines come up " why are big YouTubers not talking about this"

I took a watch and listen approach,I thought maybe they wanted to see the full scope specifically for YouTube (which is wild,but I will explain why later). Then a week went by,a new week know. Maybe they said something in their socials? Nah just memes and jokes about things unrelated,no mention of the verification.

At first I was mad, reason being the creators I follow have been sounding the alarms on book bans, the rising monopoly of platforms like meta, Youtube, Amazon etc and how their grip on data is hurting the internet. For years said creators have documented the corruption of tech companies and their ferocious pursuit of user data particularly exploiting those in the global south. Know at the nexus of survialance capitalism, big tech possibly disenfranchising large communities of people from knowldge, companies building profiles of who's online profile links to what offline identify(putting journalists, whistle blowers etc at risk).not a word not a tweet,not a community post.

If Wikipedia being forced to fight to not ask for ID did not send the alarms for over reach nothing really will. I naively thought maybe they will say something a day or two after the update. The reason why this naive was because within the first 2 weeks of OSA the damage was aparent. Young people unable to access knowledge on reddit, sexual assault,drug addiction, sex education discord channels became unavailable without age verification people unable to reach support groups on forums,multiple small LGBTQIA websites shut down as they could not afford the age verification services. Then the whole Wikimedia lawsuit with the UK government. Really nothing?

This is not to say no one is saying nothing( some notable sized channels have spoken up,but I don't want this to be a numbers game), for the only time in my life I will give the right wing a handshake,atleast the right wing side of the internet has been consistent( they lean hard into the conspiratorial with their reporting) but they are able to articulate the seriousness of the current moment. Able to match reports from privacy advocates and civil rights groups. For the lack of a better way to say it the left wing side, which have been harping on the issues if big tech and their need for ever growing data at the cost of online spaces, anonymity, opportunity for opposing voices and how this ultimately may lead to a greater divide in access to knowledge and ways to hold truth to power....age verification literally does this all and provides a new market to exploit.

Left,right, grifter I don't care. If by know they don't feel the need its truly best to just remember this moment next time they try and rile up support for a "important issue". I would think people being restricted to large parts of the internet if they don't give up their most precious data, to ai companies who I am sure will respect my wishes and delete it after verification.that a company can decide who is and isn't an adult(that's not distopian at all) and alter your Gmail and YouTube unless you give up more data(no coercion their)

My advice leave them alone, make your own video I genuinely and I mean this I love how many people who are clearly not YouTubers are making videos about this.I love how many small channels are being vocal about this.

It's sad really,with larger channels it's easier to build a platform to reach a oblivious crowd (we are the minority,the people actually following the news,most people just woke up to YouTube asking for ID). Big YouTubers also have contacts at google so it would actually provide insight to what they are doing.

But they have not said anything,and at this point that's their choice,but I would emplore you to be vocal it's not just "sensitive content" or "adult content" it's information that is locked away and it's affecting millions of people who just can't or won't verify. This isnt tee hee drama, this is genuinely reshaping who gets access to information online.

Don't wait till your guy has to say something,we all have accounts. You know broadcast youre thoughts,be the You in YouTube. It's important know to defend our right to anonymity, are you going to just let it be taken because others are not vocal? Like I said many small creators are speaking and I have sent a couple vids to people who need help understanding,I and others are also making our own videos to break it down to those uninformed. Speak know is what I am saying your "guy" is not going to.

— 0