RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/youtube • … • u/Swords_and_Words

Dynamic video quality isn't "really" supported anymore

So this is a rant that may be based on erroneous understandings, would love to be corrected if someone knows what I've gotten wrong.

Okay so it made sense why dynamic video quality was introduced in the first place:

On one hand you have consumers with inconsistent speeds who don't want the buffer to stall the video, and our benefited by the video quality automatically downshifting to maintain continuous playback.

On the other hand you have a company that is saving an immense amount of cost because it is no longer wasting immense amount of data streaming HQ videos to people who just automatically pick the highest resolution and don't actually care. If they cared they could always turn the resolution back up manually.

So far so good this makes some sense.

... Then they killed how buffering works, and that broke the whole concept.

I'm not even talking about videos no longer buffering all the way to full (for youngsters, it used to be possible to get a whole video to load and then you could leave that web page and come back at any time and that video would play no reloading the whole web page to refresh the ads no making the video start the buffer over from scratch) we lost that a long time ago.

I'm talking about the buffer decreasing massively over the last few years, while simultaneously auto deleting the buffer as soon as the video is played back or as soon as you skip/scrub ahead. With these changes they have made navigating a video involve an order of magnitude of more time wasted on waiting for the video to load.

But how does this involve the dynamic resolution you ask, kindly facilitating my rant?

The buffer behavior and size is no longer able to support the way in which dynamic resolution is implemented. Importantly, this applies at any resolution. It trying to flick back and forth between resolutions causes the user to run into the buffer limit, weather it's trying to optimize for high-resolution OR for lower resolution. It's not the speed of the download that's the problem, it's a combination of 1. how often it tries to change resolution 2. How readily the buffer is dumped annnnd 3. The positively miniscule size of the buffer these days.

We desperately need to be given back the option to have a default specific resolution, or the ability to keep the video loaded once it's been played and not delete that data when you rewind. I know they'd lose ad money on scrubbers, but the normal amount of ads for a standard watch would still play

— 0