RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/yubikey • … • u/resqucodo

Could a YubiKey be tampered with the way the CryptoBilis Ledgers were?

I’m looking at a YubiKey 5C NFC. When I add one to the cart on Yubico’s store, it suggests buying from a local reseller to avoid shipping and import taxes. I found a different reseller that lists the 5.8 firmware, and it’s the only local seller I’ve found with it.

This reseller operates in the same market as CryptoBilis (Southeast Asia) and sells the same kind of products, including Ledger and Trezor-style hardware wallets. It also isn’t listed as an authorized partner on Yubico’s website.

The CryptoBilis case is what has me nervous. It sold Ledger wallets with a hidden implant that captured recovery phrases and sent them out over LTE. Ledger confirmed it. The implant sat outside the secure element, so the devices could still look genuine. CryptoBilis was also an authorized Ledger reseller, so being on an official list didn’t protect buyers.

Is it realistic to tamper with a YubiKey, for example by adding hardware inside the casing, or swapping in a fake that passes as genuine? A YubiKey has no seed phrase to steal, but I don’t know what an attacker could gain or how hard it would be. I haven’t found any cases of YubiKeys being modified through resellers, but I’m not sure that means it can’t happen.

Has anyone seen or heard of a tampered YubiKey? And would you buy from a seller like this for the 5.8 firmware, or just pay for shipping from Yubico?

Thanks!

Edit: Thanks everyone. I ended up ordering from an official Yubico reseller, with 5.7.4 firmware instead of 5.8. Your replies convinced me that tampering with a real YubiKey is very unlikely. It’s one chip in a sealed case, so theres no room for an implant like the Ledger one. The more realistic risk is a fake or a key that got preconfigured before it reaches you. I still didnt trust the unlisted reseller though. Shipping from Yubico was tolerable, but the import fees werent, so an authorized reseller was the middle ground.

— 0