RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/zelda • … • u/Otherwise_Sun8521

[OoT] Some Disillusioned thoughts on the discourse surrounding the remake of "the greatest game of all time"

Ive been slightly triggered by the announcement of the Ocarina of time Remake and at first I couldn’t quite describe why.  Normally I’m capable of smiling and nodding, while leaving fans of other things to their excitement, but after thinking about it more I’ve narrowed down two separate points of thought that have less to do with the existence of the remake itself and rather the prevailing group think that lead to this situation in the first place.

Point 1) The assumption that Ocarina of Time is irrefutably the greatest video game ever              Even if I personally didn’t think Ocarina of Time was an outdate relic: that is such a subjective and all encompassing title I would heavily criticize and debate that assumption before I came close to agreeing to it.  To say nothing of the fact that it’s provably false by most objective metrics.  If we’re going by universal appeal Red Dead 2, Skyrim and breath of the wild have been tested and appreciated by substantially more people or even better the non action adventure titles like Pokemon, Animal Crossing, GTA and Mineraft have it beat by astronomical numbers (and no I’m not saying sales equals quality this is about sample size of people that have actually played the game).  If it’s gameplay that determines it’s superiority we would have to define what makes the objectively best gameplay, and yet regardless of what the definition was I’d seriously doubt Ocarina of Time would actually live up to that definition perfectly because if it did there would be substantially more Ocarina of Time likes made by people other than Nintendo.  I’m not going to even touch what qualifies as the best story because that is just straight up too subjective to *ever* define.  Even in a hypothetical world where it *was* the “greatest game ever” through some un identified indiscernible factor arising from the sum of its parts: a remake would be garbage and no true fan of the game would approve of it! You wouldn’t NEED/WANT to “upgrade” the music/graphics because those would be “the greatest art and music”.  You wouldn’t NEED/WANT quality of life features like gyro aiming or toggling the iron boots because all the mechanics would be the “greatest ever”.  You wouldn’t NEED/WANT them to make any of the changes that are being used to justify selling a nearly 30 year old game that is readily available on modern consoles for full price: because it would *already* be perfect!

Point 2) The frustrating discourse that results when there are those that unironically believe Ocarina of time is “the greatest video game” and those that think it’s just really good

Before we get to the point, lets clarify things, I am not so delusional as to expect Nintendo to do anything more than the bare minimum with this remake.  Ive fully accepted that it likely will be a 1:1 port of the n64 game with a fresh coat of paint and more of the obnoxious lore that’s polluted the franchise since Ocarina of times “hayday”, because they can and will get away with that.  What annoys me is the fact that because Ocarina of Time is “the greatest game ever” far too many people are either just letting that slide or worse actively arguing against any changes some people might be hoping for, not because it’s to optimistic that Nintendo would put in that kind of effort but because it would make changes they personally don’t like to the “perfect game” they are asking to be changed.  Oh sure being forced to go to the bomb dungeon before the dungeon where bombs are meaningless is completely necessary to the literary and mechanical narrative.  Oh yes enemys being immune to all damage except the designated questing device and only when their shield isn’t up, creates dynamic and engaging encounters that are always at least a little different while perfectly instilling a sense of getting stronger over the course of the game.  I mean I’m not even talking about adding the cut dungeons or filling Hyrule field with a bit more to do.  To say nothing of adding the objectively better combat engines/enemy designs from modern Zelda and opening the map up so its intentionally designed with the expectation that all of the child dungeons CAN be done before touching the master sword and do all the adult temples in any order.  Or alternatively enforce the linearity but actually live up to insinuation that this is story driven franchise by making Link into an actual character who talks while having character arcs along side navi, Zelda and the sages throughout the childhood and adult era.  No! the original Ocarina of time is “perfect” now take $90 for this handful of changes I personally deem as acceptable.  This lack of self aware critical analysis of the original game and what a remake *should* mean, is how we get Disney live action and Michael bay movies, and it makes me just a tad salty.

Anyways sorry for being a massive downer while everyones excited.  I genuinely wish I loved a game as much as you all like Ocarina of Time and hope you guys enjoy it whatever it turns out to be.

— 0